A discussion on how gerrymandering affects the electoral representation of the united states

In Pennsylvania, the Republican-dominated state legislature used gerrymandering to help defeat Democratic representative Frank Mascara. Justices Powell and Stevens said that partisan gerrymandering should be identified based on multiple factors, such as electoral district shape and adherence to local government boundaries.

Individual voters can come to have very different degrees of influence on the legislative process. Republicans apparently removed approximately 13, African-American voters from the district of Jim Raussena Republican candidate for the House of Representatives, in an attempt to tip the scales in what was once a competitive district for Democratic candidates.

They could, however, adopt a symmetric standard like what I have proposed. This is most evident in the splitline allocation of Colorado. Even in the vast majority of U.

Gerrymandering in the United States

It was redrawn in A redistricting attempt in Colorado saw Republicans attempt a similar strategy as in Texas in order to maximize Republican representation.

Moss, the Michigan state legislators, have worked together to propose a bipartisan redistricting commission in Michigan, but have met strong opposition from the Republican leadership of the Michigan House of Representatives; many legislators in other states have met similar obstacles.

Whitford, in which plaintiffs alleged that voting districts were gerrymandered unconstitutionally. While the concept of communities of interest can be very arbitrary, the Voting Rights Act mandates that some majority-minority districts be created within certain states to ensure adequate minority representation in Congress.

The Supreme Court of the United States refused to hear the case after a lengthy debate, ending the attempt. The electors allocated mainly by population among the 50 states and the District of Columbia actually choose the president and vice president, with a majority of electoral votes i.

Objective rules to create districts[ edit ] Another means to reduce gerrymandering is to create objective, precise criteria to which any district map must comply.

Trump’s victory another example of how Electoral College wins are bigger than popular vote ones

The district shown was radically redrawn by California's non-partisan commission after the census. Instances of bipartisan commission failure are more common however; one established by the Missouri legislature after the Census to redistrict that state infamously ended in intractable deadlock.

In Pennsylvania, for example, Democratic candidates for the House of Representatives received 83, more votes than Republican candidates, yet the Republican-controlled redistricting process in resulted in Democrats losing to their Republican counterparts in 13 out of Pennsylvania's 18 districts.

The Supreme Court of Colorado therefore struck down the redistricting, saying it could only occur once per decade according to the state constitution.

Eric Holder states ""We should consider reforms to the redistricting process for state and federal offices - so districts are drawn in a way that's neutral, that promotes fair and effective representation for all, and that can't be abused to protect incumbents and undercut electoral competition.

The practice of Gerrymandering predates Governor Gerry, as founding father Patrick Henry originally designed Virginian electoral districts with the intent of foiling the election of James Madison.

The Smithsonian Institute curated an exhibit that showcased the history of voting. Commissions At present, however, the only American state which consistently draws its electoral districts in this manner is Iowa, whose nonpartisan Legislative Services Bureau has sole oversight of the process.

It was redrawn from the version shown after the census. The level to which the vote is devalued and to whom it is devalued depends only on which party controls the legislature. In order to break this historically entrenched practice, mathematical algorithms may be an effective prescription for taking the passions of partisanship out of the equation.

The Republican Party used its control of Congress to secure the admission of more states in territories friendly to their party. With the increasing racial polarization of parties in the South in the U. Cromartiethe Supreme Court approved a racially focused gerrymandering of a congressional district on the grounds that the definition was not pure racial gerrymandering but instead partisan gerrymandering, which is constitutionally permissible.

Especially in a bipartisan government such as ours where there are essentially two parties in control, deadlocks result in such things as government shutdowns, as evidenced in The total effect of post redistricting added a net gain of 11 additional seats for Republicans.

November Learn how and when to remove this template message This satirical map reflects the origin of the word "gerrymander", by Elkanah Tisdale in This is often employed against politicians who represent multiple urban areas, in which larger cities will be removed from the district in order to make the district more rural.

You argue that we cannot succumb to appeals to popularity, yet you also argue that predetermined elections and worthless votes are okay because the majority is still happy. There are at least 80 known citations of the word from March through December in American newspapers. This change can actually make gerrymandering easier when raising the number of single-winner elections, as opposition groups can be more efficiently packed into smaller districts without accidentally including supporters, further increasing the number of wasted votes amongst the opposition.

Gerrymandering - Proving All Politics Is Local

In other words, Republicans won 61 percent of the seats in the Michigan State Legislature despite winning only 49 percent of the votes.

Historians widely believe that the Federalist newspaper editors Nathan Haleand Benjamin and John Russell were the instigators, but the historical record does not have definitive evidence as to who created or uttered the word for the first time. For example, in Florida adopted two state constitutional amendments that prohibit the Florida Legislature from drawing redistricting plans that favor or disfavor any political party or incumbent.

Unlike in Australia, Canada, or most European countries, anti-gerrymandering reforms have failed to gain much political traction in the United States due to entrenched political interests, however alternatives do exist.The film explores the historical, ethical, moral and racial problems raised by redistricting, i.e., the drawing of boundaries of electoral districts in the United States.

Gerrymandering covers the history of the redistricting practice, how it is used and abused, how it benefits the two major major political parties, Democrats and Republicans.

Gerrymandering is the redrawing of election district boundaries to give an electoral advantage to a particular candidate or party. It has been recognized as a part of. Gerrymandering is a problem; a Representative could have their voter base diluted across neighboring districts at the whim of the controlling party.

But Senate elections are statewide, and states. The effect of gerrymandering in four states exceeds that of population clustering in all 50 states December 8th,am by Sam Wang My New York Times piece was specifically focused on the legal question of what a party-neutral standard should look like.


Gerrymandering also has significant effects on the representation received by voters in gerrymandered districts. Because gerrymandering can be designed to increase the number of wasted votes among the electorate, the relative representation of particular groups can be drastically altered from their actual share of the voting population.

What is the effect of gerrymandering on the partisan outcomes of United States Congressional elections? A major challenge to answering this question is in determining the outcomes that would have resulted in the absence of gerrymandering.

A discussion on how gerrymandering affects the electoral representation of the united states
Rated 3/5 based on 83 review